Section 3: Exchange-Traded Funds
 

HOME

PDF VERSION

A Letter From ICI’s Chief
Economist

2005 Facts at a Glance

ICI Research: Staff and
Publications

SECTION ONE:
Overview of U.S.-Registered
Investment Companies

SECTION TWO:
Recent Mutual Fund
Trends

SECTION THREE:
Exchange-Traded Funds

SECTION FOUR:
Closed-End Funds

SECTION FIVE:
Mutual Fund Fees and
Expenses

SECTION SIX:
Mutual Fund Owners:
Who Are They and
Where Do They
Purchase Fund Shares?

SECTION SEVEN:
The Role of Mutual Funds
in Retirement and
Education Savings

DATA TABLES

APPENDIX A:
How Mutual Funds and
Investment Companies
Operate

APPENDIX B:
ICI Statistical Releases
and Research

GLOSSARY OF TERMS

FACT BOOK ARCHIVE

This section provides an overview of exchange-traded funds (ETFs), a relatively new innovation among registered investment companies.

What Is an ETF?

Development of the ETF Market

Demand for ETFs and Index Investments


Exchange-traded funds are a relatively recent innovation to the investment company concept, with the first ETF introduced in 1993 after a fund sponsor received U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission exemptive relief from various provisions of the Investment Company Act of 1940. In the 12 years since, the number of ETFs has grown to about 200, and assets have reached nearly $300 billion.

What Is an ETF?

ETFs are registered investment companies, most of which seek to mirror the return of a particular market index, such as the S&P 500 or the Russell 2000. Although most ETFs are registered as open-end funds, there are some key differences between ETFs and other open-end funds such as mutual funds.

One difference is how retail investors buy and sell shares. A retail investor in a mutual fund typically purchases or redeems shares directly with the fund. By contrast, retail shareholders in an ETF do not conduct transactions directly with the ETF but instead buy or sell ETF shares on a stock exchange, just as they would the shares of a publicly traded company. ETF shares originally enter the market through an institutional investor, known as a creation unit holder. These investors deposit with the ETF sponsor a specified basket of securities. In return for this basket of securities, the ETF issues to the creation unit holder a specified number of fund shares, which can be sold to the public through a stock exchange. A creation unit holder can liquidate its position by returning a fixed number of ETF shares to the ETF; in return, the creation unit holder receives the basket of securities it had deposited with the ETF. A retail investor in an ETF could liquidate their position by selling their ETF shares on a stock exchange.

Another feature that distinguishes ETFs from open-end funds is pricing. ETF shares may trade above or below the underlying value of the securities in the fund. Unlike a mutual fund, whose price per share is based on the fund’s net asset value (NAV), an ETF’s share price is influenced by the forces of supply and demand. For example, when investor demand increases, the ETF share price rises. However, ETFs are structured so that large differences between their share price and the value of the underlying basket of securities do not exist for long periods of time. Creation unit holders counteract the impact of supply and demand for ETF shares by buying and selling ETF shares in the market, and if necessary, by creating or redeeming creation units with the fund. In doing so, creation unit holders help keep the market price of an ETF’s shares close to the underlying value of its securities.

Net Assets of ETFs

(millions of dollars, 1993–2005)

    Investment Objective Legal Structure
Year Total Broad-Based Domestic Equity Sector/
Based
Domestic
Equity
Global/
International
Equity
Bond Index Funds Open-End UIT
1993 $464 $464

$464
1994 424
424 424
1995 1,052 1,052 1,052
1996 2,411 2,159 $252
$252
2,159
1997 6,707 6,200 506 506
6,200
1998 15,568 14,058 $484 1,026 1,510 14,058
1999 33,873 29,374 2,507 1,992 4,499 29,374
2000 65,585 60,530 3,015 2,041 10,257 55,328
2001 82,993 74,752 5,224 3,016 22,865 60,128
2002 102,143 86,985 5,919 5,324 $3,915 35,983
66,160
2003 150,983 120,430 11,901 13,984 4,667 68,306 82,677
2004 226,205 163,730 20,315 33,644 8,516 132,013 94,192
2005 296,022 186,832 28,975 65,210 15,004 200,958 95,064

Download an Excel file of this data.

Note: Components may not add to the total because of rounding.
Sources: Investment Company Institute and Strategic Insight Simfund

Development of the ETF Market

The first ETF was a broad-based domestic equity fund that tracked the S&P 500 index, and was registered as a UIT. ETFs saw modest growth until the late 1990s, when demand for exchange-traded funds accelerated as retail investors and their financial advisers became increasingly aware of these investment companies. The market for exchange-traded funds was also bolstered by demand from institutional investors, who found ETFs to be a convenient vehicle for participating in, or hedging against, broad movements in the stock market.

As demand for ETFs grew, ETF sponsors offered more funds and a greater variety of investment objectives. In the mid-1990s, ETF sponsors introduced funds that invested in foreign stock markets. More recently, sponsors have introduced funds that invest in particular market sectors or industries as well as bond index funds. For example, fund companies introduced 23 sector/industry ETFs in 2005. Sponsors have also introduced country-specific funds, funds that track commodities, and funds tracking highly specialized indexes. Since the mid-1990s, ETF sponsors have predominantly chosen to register their new funds as open-end investment companies. In 2005, most ETFs were open-end investment companies.

Number of ETFs

(1993–2005)

    Investment Objective Legal Structure
Year Total Broad-Based Domestic Equity Sector/
Based
Domestic
Equity
Global/
International
Equity
Bond Index Funds Open-End UIT
1993 1 1 1
1994 1 1 1
1995 2 2 2
1996 19 2 17 17 2
1997 19 2 17 17 2
1998 29 3 9 17 26 3
1999 30 4 9 17 26 4
2000 80 27 28 25 76 4
2001 102 34 34 34 98 4
2002 113 34 32 39 8 105 8
2003 119 39 33 41 6 111 8
2004 151 60 42 43 6 143 8
2005 201 81 65 49 6 193 8

Download an Excel file of this data.

Sources: Investment Company Institute and Strategic Insight Simfund

ETF assets have grown rapidly since the late-1990s, approximately doubling every two years. Much of this increase is attributable to net issuance of new shares. From year-end 1998 through 2005, ETFs issued $255 billion in net new shares. Investor demand for broad-based domestic equity funds accounted for much of this growth. These funds issued more than $165 billion in net new shares during this period, and assets of these funds reached $187 billion by year-end 2005. Demand for global and international ETFs also rose sharply in recent years, mirroring an increase in investor interest in mutual funds investing in foreign markets. International and global ETFs issued $39 billion in net new shares from year-end 2003 through 2005, and assets of these funds reached $65 billion.

For more complete data on exchange-traded funds, see Section 2 in the Data Tables the Statistics and Research section of this site.

Net Issuance of ETF Shares

(millions of dollars, 1993–2005)

    Investment Objective Legal Structure
Year Total Broad-Based Domestic Equity Sector/
Based
Domestic
Equity
Global/
International
Equity
Bond Index Funds Open-End UIT
1993 $442
$442
$442
1994 -28 -28 -28
1995 443 443 443
1996 1,108 842 $266
$266
842
1997 3,466 3,160 306 306 3,160
1998 6,195 5,158 $484
553 1,037 5,158
1999 11,929 10,221 1,596 112 1,708 10,221
2000 42,472 40,920 832 720 6,815 35,657
2001 31,012 26,911 2,736 1,366 13,929 17,082
2002 45,302 35,477 2,304 3,792 $3,729
20,383 24,919
2003 15,810 5,737 3,587 5,764 721 19,341 -3,531
2004 55,021 29,084 6,514 15,645 3,778 50,875 4,146
2005 53,871 16,941 6,719 23,455 6,756 55,381 -1,510

Download an Excel file of this data.

Note: Components may not add to the total because of rounding.
Sources: Investment Company Institute and Strategic Insight Simfund

Demand for ETFs and Index Investments

The growing demand for ETFs also parallels an increase in demand for indexed investments in general. By 2005, assets in index mutual funds and ETFs totaled $865 billion, which is about 9 percent of the total assets managed by all registered investment companies. Much of this growth has occurred among funds tracking broad market indexes, especially those indexes tracking large companies. Funds indexed to the S&P 500 manage about 40 percent of all assets invested in ETFs and index mutual funds. These funds are typically regarded as large-blend domestic stock funds. S&P 500 and other broad-based index funds now manage 37 percent of the large-blend domestic stock assets invested in registered investment companies. Index funds and ETFs are available in most other broad asset classes, but to date have attracted less investor interest than have broad-based domestic stock index funds.

Assets of ETFs and Index Mutual Funds Are Concentrated in Large-Blend
Domestic Equity

(billions of dollars, 2005)

Assets of ETFs and Index Mutual Funds Are Concentrated in Large-Blend

Download an Excel file of this data.

Sources: Investment Company Institute and Federal Reserve Board

 
ICI logo